Canal wall Down VS Canal wall Up Mastoidectomy
💎 Buy my Premium ENT Notes
Instant access to 270+ high-yield ENT notes, plus updates during your access period.
🇮🇳 For Indian Students
· To buy all my notes, click here💡 This post is a free outline of my YouTube video. Get my full handwritten notes using the links above.
🦻 Mastoidectomy: Canal Wall Up vs Canal Wall Down
Key Anatomical Landmarks
| Structure | Description | Clinical Importance |
|---|---|---|
| Aditus | Communication between middle ear and mastoid antrum | Surgical pathway |
| Posterior canal wall | Common wall between EAC (front) and mastoid antrum (back) | Decides CWU vs CWD |
| Spine of Henle | Bony projection in posterosuperior EAC | Surface landmark |
| McEwan's triangle (Suprameatal triangle) | Bounded by: supramastoid crest (superior), posterosuperior EAC line (anterior), tangent joining them (posterior) | Mastoid antrum ~1.5 cm deep |
| Facial bridge | Part of posterior bony canal wall overlying fossa incudis | Removed in Canal wall down surgery for exposure |
| Facial ridge | Posterior canal wall overlying bony facial canal | Lowered during surgery, cannot be removed fully (risk of Facial Nerve injury) |
| Anterior buttress | Junction of posterior canal wall with tegmen | Surgical landmark |
| Posterior buttress | Junction of posterior canal wall with EAC floor | Surgical landmark |
Definition of Mastoidectomy
| Term | Definition |
|---|---|
| Mastoidectomy | Surgical removal of mastoid air cells in temporal bone to eradicate disease & access middle ear cleft |
| Canal Wall Up (CWU) | Posterior canal wall preserved → mastoid cavity remains separate from EAC |
| Canal Wall Down (CWD) | Posterior canal wall removed → mastoid cavity + EAC become one large cavity |
Goals
| Procedure | Aim |
|---|---|
| Canal Wall Up (CWU) | Eradicate disease while preserving near-normal canal anatomy and hearing mechanism |
| Canal Wall Down (CWD) | Eradicate disease with wide exteriorization, ensuring a safe, dry ear |
Common Surgeries
| Canal Wall Up (CWU) | Canal Wall Down (CWD) |
|---|---|
| Cortical mastoidectomy (aka Simple/Schwartz/Complete Mastoidectomy) | Atticotomy |
| Combined approach tympanoplasty (CAT) | Atticoantrostomy |
| – | Modified radical mastoidectomy |
| – | Radical mastoidectomy |
Indications
| Canal Wall Up (CWU) | Canal Wall Down (CWD) |
|---|---|
| Limited cholesteatoma (attic/antrum only) | Extensive/recurrent cholesteatoma |
| Good Eustachian tube function | Posterior canal wall erosion |
| Reliable patient follow-up | Poor Eustachian tube function |
| Preferred first surgery (esp. children) | Unreliable follow-up |
| – | Complicated CSOM (intracranial/extracranial) |
| – | Revision surgeries |
Exposure & Clearance
| Canal Wall Up (CWU) | Canal Wall Down (CWD) |
|---|---|
| Limited exposure – sinus tympani, anterior epitympanum, hypotympanum difficult to visualize | Wide exposure – direct view of all recesses |
| Higher chance of residual disease | More complete clearance |
Recurrence
| Canal Wall Up (CWU) | Canal Wall Down (CWD) |
|---|---|
| Higher recurrence/residual disease (10–40%) | Lower recurrence (2–10%), easier detection |
Hearing Outcomes
| Canal Wall Up (CWU) | Canal Wall Down (CWD) |
|---|---|
| Better – normal canal acoustics, ossicular reconstruction easier | Poorer – large cavity, less favorable acoustics, though ossiculoplasty still possible |
Postoperative Canal Appearance
| Canal Wall Up (CWU) | Canal Wall Down (CWD) |
|---|---|
| Normal EAC preserved | Enlarged meatus with large mastoid cavity |
Cavity Care & Follow-up
| Canal Wall Up (CWU) | Canal Wall Down (CWD) |
|---|---|
| No cavity care required; ear is self-cleansing | Lifelong periodic cleaning (aural toileting) |
| Requires strict follow-up & second-look surgery (6–18 months) | Less stringent follow-up needed |
Complications
| Canal Wall Up (CWU) | Canal Wall Down (CWD) |
|---|---|
| Higher residual/recurrent disease, retraction pocket formation | Cavity-related problems: otorrhea, granulation tissue, meatal stenosis |
Patient Limitations
| Canal Wall Up (CWU) | Canal Wall Down (CWD) |
|---|---|
| No long-term restrictions; swimming allowed | Swimming/bathing restrictions (risk of infection, caloric vertigo) |
Auditory Rehabilitation
| Canal Wall Up (CWU) | Canal Wall Down (CWD) |
|---|---|
| Easier to fit hearing aids | Hearing aid fitting difficult due to large cavity/infections |
Advantages vs Disadvantages
| Canal Wall Up (CWU) Advantages | Canal Wall Up (CWU) Disadvantages |
|---|---|
| Preserves EAC anatomy | Limited exposure |
| Better hearing outcome | Higher recurrence (10–40%) |
| No cavity, no lifelong care | Requires second-look surgery |
| Fewer lifestyle restrictions | Retraction pocket risk if Eustachian Tube function poor |
| Preferred in children | – |
| Canal Wall Down (CWD) Advantages | Canal Wall Down (CWD) Disadvantages |
|---|---|
| Excellent exposure, complete clearance | Creates large cavity → cavity related issues |
| Lower recurrence (2–10%) | Lifelong cleaning needed |
| Recurrence easily visible | Water restrictions (no swimming) |
| No need for second look | Cosmetic deformity (enlarged meatus, postauricular hollow) |
| Useful in unreliable follow up | Worse hearing outcome, hearing aid fitting difficult |
Types of Mastoidectomy (Quick Definitions)
| Surgery | Type | Key Features |
|---|---|---|
| Cortical mastoidectomy | CWU | Exenteration of all accessible mastoid air cells; posterior canal wall intact; preserves TM & ossicles |
| Radical mastoidectomy | CWD | Removes mastoid + middle ear + attic + antrum; posterior canal wall removed; removes TM remnants, all ossicles except stapes footplate; ET opening closed |
| Modified radical mastoidectomy | CWD | Like radical but preserves TM remnants, functioning ossicles, and ET opening |
~~~~~~~~
📝 All topics and questions from this post are explained in detail in my Premium ENT Notes, which are designed for clinical understanding and exam success.
Residency is hard enough. Studying for it shouldn't be 😊
💎 Buy my Premium ENT Notes
Instant access to 270+ high-yield ENT notes, plus updates during your access period.
🇮🇳 For Indian Students
· To buy all my notes, click here~~~~~~~~
Related ENT Notes & Lectures
Otology
Abscesses in relation to MastoidAcute Mastoiditis VS FurunculosisAcute Necrotizing Otitis MediaAcute Otitis Media - Causes, Symptoms and TreatmentAnatomy of External EarAnatomy of Facial NerveAnatomy of Facial Nerve – BranchesAnatomy of Facial Nerve – Functional ComponentsAnatomy of Facial Nerve – Nuclei & CourseAnatomy of Inner EarAnatomy of Middle Ear - ContentsAnatomy of Middle Ear - Walls & PartsAnatomy of Tympanic MembraneBenign Intracranial Hypertension (Otitic Hydrocephalus)CholesteatomaChronic Suppurative Otitis Media (CSOM)Complications of Acute Otitis MediaComplications of CSOMComplications of MastoidectomyCortical MastoidectomyExtracranial Complications of CSOMFalse Negative Rinne Test ExplainedGlomus Tumor Signs Explained | Aquino Sign, Brown Sign, Phelps Sign & Rising Sun SignGradenigo SyndromeGrommet / Tympanostomy tube / Ventilation tubeHalo Sign Explained in ENTHow to Draw a Normal Tympanic MembraneHow to Draw Tympanic Membrane PerforationsIce Cream Cone Sign Explained in ENTInner Ear fluids - Perilymph and EndolymphInside out VS Outside in MastoidectomyIntracranial Complications of CSOMLabyrinthine FistulaLabyrinthitisLandmarks of Facial Nerve in Mastoid and Parotid surgeriesMalignant Otitis Externa (Skull Base Osteomyelitis)MastoiditisModified Radical MastoidectomyMyringotomy with Grommet InsertionOrgan of Corti – Anatomy, Structure and Clinical RelevanceOtitis Media with EffusionOtogenic Brain AbscessOtosclerosis Part 1 - Causes, Pathogenesis, Types, PathologyOtosclerosis Part 2 - Symptoms, Signs, Investigations, Differential diagnosisOtosclerosis Part 3 - TreatmentOtosclerosis Signs Explained | Schwartz sign, Carhart’s notch, Halo sign, Paracusis willisiiPerichondritis - Boxer’s Ear / Cauliflower EarPetrositisRadical MastoidectomyReferred Pain in the EarSade Classification - Pars Tensa RetractionSigmoid Sinus ThrombosisSigns in Acoustic Neuroma | Hitzelberger Sign & Ice Cream Cone SignSigns in Normal CT Temporal Bone | Ice Cream Cone Sign & Snake Eyes SignSigns in Sigmoid Sinus Thrombosis | Delta Sign, Griesinger Sign & Picket Fence FeverTheories of Cholesteatoma - Wittmack, Habermann, Ruedi, SadeTos Classification - Pars Flaccida RetractionTuning Fork Tests in ENT | Rinne, Weber, Absolute Bone Conduction, Schwabach, Bing & Gelle TestTympanoplasty Part 1 - Definition, Types, Grafts, Indications, ContraindicationsTympanoplasty Part 2 - Approaches, Techniques, Steps & ComplicationsTypes of Cholesteatoma - Congenital & Acquired CholesteatomaTypes of Tympanoplasty - Wullstein Classification
Surgery
Complications of MastoidectomyComplications of TracheostomyCortical MastoidectomyDecannulationInside out VS Outside in MastoidectomyModified Radical MastoidectomyMyringotomy with Grommet InsertionParadise Criteria for TonsillectomyPost Tonsillectomy Hemorrhage - Primary, Reactionary and Secondary HemorrhageRadical MastoidectomyRose PositionSeptoplasty Incisions | Killian's Incision, Freer's (Hemitransfixion) Incision & Transfixion IncisionSeptoplasty Part 1 - Definition, Goldman Criteria, Indications & ContraindicationsTonsillectomy Part 1 - Definition, Indications and ContraindicationsTonsillectomy Part 2 - Tonsillectomy Techniques - Hot & Cold MethodsTonsillectomy Part 3 - Hot Tonsillectomy vs Interval TonsillectomyTonsillectomy Part 4 - Procedure & Post operative careTonsillectomy Part 5 - Complications of TonsillectomyTracheostomy - Definition, Indications, Contraindications & TypesTracheostomy - Procedure, Steps & Postoperative careTympanoplasty Part 1 - Definition, Types, Grafts, Indications, ContraindicationsTympanoplasty Part 2 - Approaches, Techniques, Steps & Complications
~~~~~~~~